HIPEC vs PIPAC: comparison of advanced techniques in intraperitoneal chemotherapy

Dos cirujanos realizando una operación con trajes de protección y máscaras faciales. Están concentrados en el procedimiento, iluminados por luces quirúrgicas en un entorno estéril de sala de operaciones.

Peritoneal carcinomatosis or peritoneal metastasis is a stage of advanced cancer that occurs when cancer cells spread throughout the peritoneum, the membrane lining the abdominal cavity and abdominal internal organs.

The combination of systemic chemotherapy, intraperitoneal chemotherapy and surgery has improved the prognosis of carcinomatosis in recent decades. Among the most prominent treatments, cytoreductive surgery combined with the administration of hyperthermic intraperitoneal chemotherapy (HIPEC) is an effective alternative for patients with a limited extent of disease. When the patient is not a candidate for cytoreductive surgery and HIPEC, the alternative is systemic chemotherapy and some advanced intaeperitoneal therapy techniques such as PIPAC or ePIPAC.

 

What is HIPEC?

HIPEC is a treatment for patients with advanced cancer, which has spread through the peritoneum.

The intervention is performed after completing cytoreductive surgery and consists of the administration of chemotherapy at a temperature between 40-43ºC for a specific time, between 60-120 minutes.

The hot chemotherapy dose is administered in the form of a perfusion, which is removed from the abdomen at the end of the operation. The aim is to eliminate any tumor cells that may be free in the abdomen after surgery.

Which patients can be treated with Cytoreduction Surgery and HIPEC?

Patients with peritoneal carcinomatosis or peritoneal metastases, whose primary tumor may be located in:

Abdomen

– Ovaries
– Stomach
– Appendix (one of its variants is peritoneal pseudomyxoma)
– Colon
– Small Intestine
– Pancreas
– Endometrium,
– Appendix (one of its variants is peritoneal pseudomyxoma)
– Sarcoma
– Cholangiocarcinoma

– Kidney cancer

Outside the abdomen

– Lung cancer
– Breast cancer

– Melanoma

In the peritoneum itself

– Peritoneal mesothelioma

– Primary peritoneal cancer

 

What is PIPAC?

Pressurized Intraperitoneal Aerosol Chemotherapy (PIPAC) is indicated in patients with peritoneal carcinomatosis of any origin where cytoreductive surgery cannot be performed because the disease is too extensive or because it affects unresectable areas.

By means of laparoscopic surgery under general anesthesia, chemotherapy is applied in the form of an aerosol or spray and with pressure. This technique improves the penetration of chemotherapy into the tumor nodules, without the chemotherapy passing into the blood (or a minimal amount).

Tumor response rate and slowing of tumor progression has been demonstrated and prolonged survival seems likely in patients who have benefited from this new procedure. Fortunately, this minimally invasive procedure is associated with a low rate of side effects and acceptable surgical risks.

Which patients can be treated with PIPAC?

Patients with cancer that has spread to the peritoneum, who are not candidates for HIPEC because of the advanced stage of the cancer and are resistant to chemotherapy.

 

Comparison between HIPEC and PIPAC

Efficacy

The efficacy of HIPEC varies according to different factors:

  • Peritoneal carcinomatosis index (PCI)
  • Type of primary tumor
  • Stage of the disease
  • Completeness of cytoreduction

PIPAC: approximately 16% of patients treated with PIPAC have such a significant response that they may end up being treated with surgery and HIPEC.

Invasiveness

HIPEC is administered after cytoreduction surgery, which can be performed either by conventional open surgical approach or by minimally invasive laparoscopic approach.

PIPAC is a minimally invasive procedure, very well tolerated by patients. By means of laparoscopic surgery under general anesthesia, the abdomen is accessed with 2 or 3 incisions of 1 cm in diameter.

Time and recovery

After cytoreduction surgery and HIPEC, patients may be hospitalized for 7 to 20 days. The normal course of hospitalization begins in the first 24-48 hours, usually in the ICU for close monitoring. Subsequently, the patient is on the ward until he/she is in a suitable condition to return home.

In contrast, after the PIPAC procedure, being minimally invasive, the patient can go home the next day.

Long-term results

At present, treatments for peritoneal carcinomatosis remain limited. Standard palliative chemotherapy often provides only modest improvement in prognosis with low tumor response rates. In addition, this treatment is associated with a significant risk of harmful side effects.

Multimodality management combining systemic chemotherapy – complete cytoreduction surgery and HIPEC – is an effective alternative for patients with disease of limited extent, and which does not affect areas known to be unresectable.

According to data published in the prestigious journal The Lancet, the percentage of patients with very advanced disease in the peritoneum, who are not candidates for HIPEC due to the advanced stage of the cancer and who are resistant to chemotherapy, in whom a response is achieved with PIPAC, is:

  • Up to 88% in ovarian cancer
  • Up to 91% of patients with stomach cancer
  • Up to 86% of patients with colorectal cancer
  • Up to 75% of patients with peritoneal mesothelioma.

In conclusion, both HIPEC and PIPAC represent innovative strategies in the treatment of peritoneal carcinomatosis, each with its own indications. HIPEC, combined with cytoreduction surgery, offers an effective option for patients with limited extent of disease, improving long-term prognosis. On the other hand, PIPAC is presented as an alternative for patients who are not candidates for HIPEC due to the advanced stage of their cancer. PIPAC allows better tolerance and faster recovery, showing promising results in slowing tumor progression and response in several types of cancer. The choice between HIPEC and PIPAC depends on multiple factors, including the stage of the cancer, the extent of the disease and the overall condition of the patient, underlining the importance of a personalized approach in the treatment of peritoneal carcinomatosis.

Dr. Rosa María Morera

Radiation Oncology

  • Specialist in Radiation Oncology.
  • Degree in Medicine and Surgery.  Faculty of Medicine, Complutense University of Madrid (2-8-1990).
  • Head of the Radiation Oncology Department, Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid.
  • Expert with university micro-credential mention in Physics, Technology and Protontherapy. King Juan Carlos University.
  • Higher University Course in Design and Management of Proton Therapy Centres. King Juan Carlos University.
  • XIX Programme of Senior Management in Health Institutions. IESE Business School. University of Navarra.
  • Master in Administration and Management of Health Services XXIV Edition (2013-2014). Pompeu Fabra University.
  • Doctoral Thesis Reading: ‘Radical thoracic irradiation and pulmonary functional study in patients with locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer. Systematic review and prospective case series’ . Qualification of outstanding ‘cum laude’.
  • Doctorate courses: Complutense University of Madrid (1995-1997).
  • She is a researcher in numerous clinical trials, publishing several national and international scientific articles.

Dr. Jose María Oliver

Breast radiology

  • Breast radiologist and specialist in cryoblation of breast lesions in the IVOQA Breast Unit.
  • Degree in Medicine and Surgery from the University of Navarra (1983-1989). Specialisation via MIR in Radiology. Number 289.
  • Specialist in radiology in several renowned hospitals, international reference and pioneer in the application of cryoablation to breast pathology in Spain.
  • Head of the Breast Radiology Section at the Hospital Universitario La Paz.
  • Member of the Spanish Society of Medical Radiology (SERAM) and the Spanish Society of Diagnostic Imaging (SEDIM).

Dr. Jesús Cañete Gómez

General and Digestive Surgery. Oncological Surgery

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery from the University of Seville (2000- 2006).
  • Specialist in colon and rectal cancer surgery using a minimally invasive approach.
  • Training in transanal rectal cancer treatment (TAMIS and TaTME).
    Training in minimally invasive surgery at Jackson Memorial Hospital (Miami).
  • Specialist in General Surgery at Viamed Fatima Hospital, Seville (currently).
  • Doctor of Medicine from the University of Seville (‘cum laude’).
  • Associate Professor at the University of Seville Founder of the surgical team Laparoscopic Surgery Seville – MISS (Minimally Invasive Surgical Solutions) – minimally invasive surgical techniques in scheduled and emergency surgery.
  • He has written numerous publications in journals and books and is a member of the Spanish Society of Obesity Surgery (SECO), as well as the Spanish Association of Surgeons (AEC) and the Andalusian Association of Surgeons (ASAC).

Dr. Juan José Segura Sampedro

General and digestive surgery. Oncological Surgery

  • Degree in Medicine and Surgery from the University of Seville. 2003-2009.
  • Specialist in peritoneal carinomatosis.
  • Doctor of Medicine from the University of Seville (‘cum laude’).
  • Oncological Surgeon in the Section of Peritoneal, Retroperitoneal and Soft Parts Oncological Surgery, Department of General and Digestive System Surgery, Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid.
  • Associate Professor of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, University of the Balearic Islands, Palma de Mallorca.
  • 3IP in the Research Group in Advanced Oncological Surgery, m-Health and Innovation in Surgical Technology, Institute for Health Research of the Balearic Islands (IdISBa), Palma de Mallorca.
  • He has written numerous publications in journals and books and is a member of the Spanish Society of Surgical Oncology (SEOQ), the Spanish Society of Coloproctology (AECP), the Spanish Association of Surgeons (AEC), the European Society of Oncological Surgery (ESSO) and the Spanish Group of Peritoneal Oncological Surgery (GECOP).

Pablo Soto

Specialist in sports training for oncology patients

  • Higher Degree in Dietetics (2020-2022)
  • Treatment and rehabilitation of cancer patients

Dr. Gonzalez Larriba

Medical oncology

  • Professor of Medical Oncology at the Complutense University of Madrid
  • Head of the Medical Oncology Section of the Hospital Clínico San Carlos in possession of the European Certificate in Oncology
  • Recognition of 6 six-year research periods + 1 six-year period of knowledge transfer
  • Master in Oncology Services Management by the University of Alcala de Henares
  • Visiting Professor of Oncology at the University of Palermo (Italy)
  • Multiple stays in international centres (Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, Gustave Roussy Institute, University of Lyon, Princess Margaret Hospital in Toronto, University of Pittsburgh)
  • Maximum recognition of the Professional Career by the Regional Ministry of Health of the Community of Madrid
  • Director of the Master’s Degree in Genitourinary Tumours at the Complutense University of Madrid
  • Founder and member of the Board of Directors of the Spanish Lung Cancer Group, Spanish Genitourinary Tumour Group and Spanish Melanoma Group
  • Member of the Board of Directors of the Spanish Society of Medical Oncology
  • Miembro de la European Society of Medical Oncology, American Society of Clinical Oncology, International Association for the Study od Lung Cancer, etc.
  • Author of more than 300 scientific articles, 400 conference papers and 60 scientific books, as well as speaker in more than 400 conference papers

Francisco Flores

Physiotherapy

  • Graduate in physiotherapy. UEM.
  • Master’s degree in respiratory physiotherapy. UNIVERSITAT
  • ROVIRA i VIRGILI.
  • MASTER specialist in conservative and invasive physiotherapy of myofascial pain syndrome and fibromyalgia. UAH.
  • SPIROMETRIST by the ERS-SEPAR for the performance and interpretation of SPIROMETRY.
  • MASTER Specialist in intratissue percutaneous electrolysis treatments EPI.
  • Specialist in the use and application of the INDIBA ACTIV system.
  • MASTER Specialist in Biomechanical Analysis, Intervention and Treatment “Check yourMOtion”.
  • NATIONAL CLASSIFIER for athletes with cerebral palsy.
  • NATIONAL CLASSIFIER of athletics for people with physical disabilities.
  • RESEARCH PROJECT: “Respiratory physiotherapy as a treatment for ARVC in high performance athletes”.

Dr. Javier Heras Aznar

BREAST UNIT

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery from Universidad Autonoma de Madrid 1992.
  • Specialist via MIR in Family Medicine at Hospital Universitario Ramón y Cajal 1994-1996.
  • Specialist via MIR in OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY at Hospital Universitario Santa Cristina in Madrid 1997-2001.
  • Specialized in the last 27 years in Gynecological Oncology and Breast Pathology, both malignant and benign, with experience in Oncoplastic Surgery.
  • Specialization Course in Oncoplastic Breast Surgery 2015.
  • Coordinator of the Breast Unit and the Breast Tumors and Gynecology Oncology Committee in Hospital Universitario Infanta Sofía.
  • Main Author of the Breast Unit Accreditation Project (Hospital Universitario Infanta Sofía) 2019-2020.

Dr. Beatriz García-Conde

DIGESTIVE SYSTEM MEDICINE

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery.
  • MIR specialisation in Digestive System Medicine, Puerta de Hierro University Hospital in Majadahonda. Currently working at the 12 de Octubre University Hospital.
  • Specialist in capsule endoscopy and in diagnostic and therapeutic endoscopy: chromoendoscopy, colon cancer screening, digestive dilatations, PEG placement, endoluminal vacuum therapy (fistulas/leaks), polypectomy/mucosectomy.
  • She also a general digestive consultant with a Master’s Degree in Neurogastroenterology.

Dr. Micaela Riat Castro Zocchi

DIGESTIVE SYSTEM MEDICINE

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery.
  • MIR specialisation in Digestive System Medicine, Princesa Hospital (Madrid).
  • Clinical consultation. Diagnostic and therapeutic endoscopy: Chromoendoscopy, Colon Cancer Screening, Placement of digestive prosthesis (oesophagus, colon), Digestive dilatations, PEG Placement, Endoluminal Vacuum Therapy (fistulas/leaks), Polypectomy/mucosectomy. Experience in Bariatric Endoscopy: Intragastric balloon.

Dr. Diana Fresneda Cuesta

DIGESTIVE SYSTEM MEDICINE

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery.
  • MIR specialisation in Digestive System Medicine, Jiménez Díaz Foundation. (Madrid)
  • Clinical consultation. Specialist in Endoscopic Capsule and in Diagnostic and Therapeutic Endoscopy: Chromoendoscopy, Colon Cancer Screening, Ligation of Oesophagus Varices, Placement of digestive prosthesis (oesophagus, colon), Digestive dilatations, PEG Placement, Endoluminal Vacuum Therapy (fistulas/leaks), Polypectomy/mucosectomy. Experience in bariatric endoscopy: intragastric balloon, POSE method and Endo-sleeve with POSE system, etc.

Dr. Teresa Valdés Lacasa

DIGESTIVE SYSTEM MEDICINE

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery
  • MIR specialisation in Digestive System Medicine, 12 de Octubre University Hospital (Madrid). Advanced Endoscopy Fellowship (ERCP and digestive prostheses) at Ninewells Hospital (United Kingdom). 2020-2021.
  • Clinical consultation and abdominal ultrasound.
  • Specialist in pancreatico-biliary conditions and therapeutic endoscopy: ERCP, placement of digestive prostheses (oesophagus, duodenum, colon, biliary), digestive dilatations, placement of PEGs, endoluminal vacuum therapy (fistulas/leaks), polypectomy/mucosectomy.

Dr. Andrés J. del Pozo García, MD. PhD.

DUAL SPECIALISATION IN DIGESTIVE SYSTEM MEDICINE / FAMILY AND COMMUNITY MEDICINE

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery.
  • Dual specialised training (MIR) at the Princesa University Hospital (Madrid).
  • Specialist in Digestive System Medicine and Specialised in Family and Community Medicine
  • PhD in Medicine from the Autonomous University of Madrid. Cum Laude. 2020.
  • Member of S.E.P.D, S.E.E.D., A.E.G, E.S.G.E, AESPANC, Board Member of GETTEMO; Consultant of Apollo Endosurgery in 2021.

Dr. José María Abadal Villayandre

SPECIALIST IN VASCULAR INTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery from Navarra University.
  • MIR specialisation in Radiology, Radiodiagnosis at Gregorio Marañón University Hospital.
  • PhD in Radiodiagnosis from the Complutense University of Madrid. Cum Laude Doctoral Thesis.
  • Specialist in Vascular Interventional Radiology, accreditation from the Spanish Society of Interventional Radiology.
  • European Board Interventional Radiology (EBIR) Health Sciences) at Alfonso X el Sabio University. 2010-2014.
  • Medical Director of the “Centro de Radiología y Diagnóstico por Imagen”.
  • Scientific and research activity with numerous publications and research studies.
  • Director and professor of Interventional Vascular Radiology at the I-XI Endo-school. Teaching activity.
  • Member of SERAM (Spanish Society of Medical Radiology), CIRSE (Cardiovascular Interventional Radiology Society Europe), and Secretary of SERVEI (Spanish Society of Interventional Vascular Radiology).

Belén Pérez Peiro. Psychologist

SPECIALIST IN PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY

  • Graduate in Psychology
  • Clinical psychologist, Gregorio Marañón University General Hospital, Psycho-oncology, Gynaecological Psychology, Neuropsychology, Detoxification and Out-patient Hospital, inflammatory bowel disease and teenagers.
  • Clinical activity at the Niño Jesús Children’s University Hospital, Psychiatric and Eating Disorder Units.
  • Expert qualification in Psychosomatic Medicine and Health Psychology.
  • Expert qualification in Psychopathology and Psychiatry from the Spanish Society of Psychosomatic Medicine and Medical Psychology.
  • Specialist qualification in Psychotherapy and projective techniques, both of which are recognised by the Madrid Official Association of Psychologists.

Dr. Ana María Moreno

SPECIALIST IN INTERNAL MEDICINE AND NUTRITIONAL PREHABILITATION

  • Graduate in Medicine and Surgery. 1986– 1992.
  • Extraordinary Graduation Award. 1992.
  • MIR specialisation in Internal Medicine. Number 283.
  • Master’s Degree in Palliative Care from Valladolid University. 2011.
  • University Master’s Degree in Advanced Chronic Nursing and palliative care from Antonio de Nebrija University. 2017.
  • PhD Courses 1993.
  • Extensive professional career in many renowned hospitals.
  • Head of Internal Medicine Services at Viamed Santa Elena (Madrid). September 2021 – Present.
  • Teaching and research work.
  • Numerous publications and papers. Participation in courses and seminars.